I’ve seen some Lemmy apps/interfaces do that as well. So maybe it’s not all that different?
I think what they’re suggesting is that a post would have a merged view of all comments from all the different duplicate posts in all the different communities it’s posted in.
To combine the comments would probably require a revision to the lemmy protocol, plus an even bigger one to the backend software to keep backwards compatibility
If it is possible to detect which posts are cross posts, it should be possible to create a client app that combines the threads. Maybe give you an option to chose which one to post your comment.
I feel like cross-posts should share comment threads…
Now comment threads are split across 6 communities.
Kbin website implements this.
Oh really? That’s interesting.
Well, to be precise, kbin groups posts with the same URL.
I’ve seen some Lemmy apps/interfaces do that as well. So maybe it’s not all that different?
I think what they’re suggesting is that a post would have a merged view of all comments from all the different duplicate posts in all the different communities it’s posted in.
I see the cross posts all at the top but comments are separate
To combine the comments would probably require a revision to the lemmy protocol, plus an even bigger one to the backend software to keep backwards compatibility
If it is possible to detect which posts are cross posts, it should be possible to create a client app that combines the threads. Maybe give you an option to chose which one to post your comment.
I don’t think it should be a client feature. It should be federated, like the posts are.
I think the issue with federation of comments is moderation of comments.
You might not like the admins of
example.org:foobut you might have no issues with the admins ofexample.com:foo.