Ok , here we go.

I like lemmy a lot.

Mastodon and all the others are too complicated with too many dam options for threads. Not to mention I hate the Twitter layout.

Like look,

I want lemmy to have more users. The lack of engagement here is just beyond sad.

I’ve seen a lot of lemmy instances with like 1 user a month. Seriously? What the fuck?

I’m entertaining a thought to create a lemmy instance, but is there even a point? Should i even bother?

I feel like the issue with these reddit alternatives, is the LACK of content and users.

What do you think?

  • Cold Hotman@nrsk.no
    1·
    2 years ago

    some people will come and stick around.

    I’ve been browsing around a lot of communities on practically all known lemmy servers. Some communities or instances provide regular content, several times a day, for months or years. Still no upvotes, discussion or visibility.

    Why? Well, how do people “come by” before they stick around? They have to actively browse every single instance and hunt down anything that isn’t already “mainstream” enough for other users to already subscribe to the community and pull it to the instance.

    The complete lack of organic sharing when it comes to communites is a big hold-back. If lemmy-instances automatically shared all instances edit: communities with eachother instead of just the ones individuals subscribe to it would be much easier to gain visibility by “offering regular quality content” because more posts equals more visibility.

    For the majority of communities at this time, regularly posting content is regularly shouting into the void.

    • graphito@lemmy.ml
      1·
      2 years ago

      You got me curious! Could you share some of your hidden gems of lemmyverse: has <10 subs and posts quality content at least once a month?

      • Cold Hotman@nrsk.no
        1·
        2 years ago

        What one consider quality content is very subjective, but one example could be https://exploding-heads.com/c/digitslfreedom with 400+ posts, 6 users per month, 3 per week, 1 per day. 5 posts last 24 hours. 19 subs tbf, but very little activity beyond the occasional upvote.

        NRSK’s own communites like https://nrsk.no/c/norway and https://nrsk.no/c/videos are two other communities who posts largely extraordinarily good content (me practically being the only poster could be relevant to this statement) on a regular basis. Yet the only “significant” growth I’ve seen is directly related to advertising the community by crossposting, mentions and in other ways actively pushing it on others.

        Of course it could be due to most others consider it low quality, but I believe the lack of visibility is a bigger factor.

    • guojing@lemmy.ml
      1·
      2 years ago

      Isnt this similar to Reddit? There I also found interesting communities mostly when other people recommended it, and not through some kind of algorithm. If you just got a list of all federated communities, most of them would probably be dead or irrelevant.

      • Cold Hotman@nrsk.no
        1·
        2 years ago

        found interesting communities mostly when other people recommended it

        That’s one way of doing it. The way I found the most interesting and niché subreddits was by hanging out in /all/new.

        just got a list of all federated communities, most of them would probably be dead or irrelevant.

        That seems to be the current status quo on lemmy. When you browse your homeinstance’s federated communities or visit a different instance and list their local communities, it seems there’s not very much logic to the sorting. There’s no way of sorting them by i.e. activity.

        That’s why I go to /all/new on lemmy as well. I see every new post to every federated community. It’s a gauge of activity and I see communities I didn’t know existed because other users subscribed to them and pulled them in.

        The ideal /all/new for me would show new posts from all communities.