So you’re trying to connect a device to your PC which is literally made by Linux’ biggest opponent in the OS market who does not provide drivers for other platforms so that the driver has to be reverse engineered and then complain that this is a bit hacky?
I mean I will give you that it’s a difficult position for Linux but as I am just trying to get things done with my computer, I do not see it as a valid excuse. Especially when PlayStation controllers work just fine on Windows. https://ds4-windows.com/ All done via a GUI. Xbox controllers are the most common controller used. It uses the most common interface to use them, it’s hard to justify them not working out of the box, and on a lot of distros they do work out of the box.
Package management (including gfx drivers) can be done in YaST with GUI.
Yes, it can be. But tell me, how do you know what driver is currently being used? (or even what one to install, which Windows will tell you, some distros will tell you what graphics card drivers to install but nothing else.)
Luckily, linux drivers are provided as kernel modules and there should be no need to update, uninstall or rollback device drivers besides when the manufacturers don’t comply to open standards.
Clearly, drivers need to be updated or even rolled back. There have been updates to the open-source drivers. No driver is perfect so they do break things and need to get reverted. I don’t understand your point here because now Nvidia and AMD both use open-source kernel modules. https://github.com/NVIDIA/open-gpu-kernel-modules as well as the AMD ones https://github.com/radeonopencompute/rock-kernel-driver/ these drivers are constantly getting updates.
Despite all that, terminal is incredibly useful and can get tasks done orders of magnitude faster than the best GUI ever could.
I don’t care, my opinion differs. Linux is supposed to be the OS of choice and customization. I’d rather not drop down to the terminal. I feel like I can understand a GUI better. It’s not about speed here, it’s about accuracy and ease of use. I want to do the thing so I can move on to doing other things. Maintaining a computer is not a hobby for me, it’s a means to an end. I just want to have my computer work so I can get back to writing code, playing games, and watching shows. Anything that gets in the way is not really worth the time.
Don’t get me wrong, the Linux command line is nice, I’ve written in bash for the last 10 years, it’s far better than Batch or PowerShell and it’s why I use WSL for scripting things on Windows. I write automation for things like build scripts and uploaders and things to make my life easier but I am not about to do this for my computer which should be able to maintain itself for the most part. This is what Windows does and I do not expect less from Linux just because it’s open source.
I complain about the tasks that ideally with a good OS, I should only do once and literally never again until I reinstall my OS for some reason. On Linux a kernel will be updated and my graphics kernel module won’t have a new package for the new kernel and I’ll get bricked.
Especially when PlayStation controllers work just fine on Windows.
Ps-controllers also work great on Linux! Have to running in Batocera, absolutely no problem plug&play (well, connect and play).
Xbox controllers are the most common controller used.
Are they? I doubt that. I don’t know how good or bad they work on Linux, but PS, Steam-Controller, noname-Controllers from AliExpress, Logitech… all working without cli. So maybe Microsoft is the problem here?
But tell me, how do you know what driver is currently being used? (or even what one to install, which Windows will tell you, some distros will tell you what graphics card drivers to install but nothing else.)
Windows will tell you? If you have a dedicated gpu and want to actually use it you have to go to the website of the chipset vendor, search for the driver, look for the doenload, download it, open the downloaded file, allow changes to the system, click next an obscene amount of times while unchecking all the bloat that is bundled with the driver, wait, click again, and then you’re good to go. Maybe you are asked to log into your geforce experience account, and then you’re good to go. Having some program always running in the background, collecting data, hugging ressources. On Linux you have the choice to install the proprietary or the open source driver. And it just works (at least for AMD since 2019 for me)
Clearly, drivers need to be updated or even rolled back. There have been updates to the open-source drivers.
In Linux most drivers are kernel modules and you generally don’t interact with them at all. Everything just works. Exceptions are gfx cards and shitty wireless chipsets. Maybe FFB driving wheels. Besides that, every driver update is tested and happens automatically when your package manager installs updates (which can be done via GUI).
No driver is perfect so they do break things and need to get reverted.
That is just objectively wrong. Simple drivers for simple devices can be implemented perfectly and so can more complicated ones, which they sometimes even are. Tell me which driver you had to “revert”. Was it for a NVIDIA GPU?
I just want to have my computer work so I can get back to writing code, playing games, and watching shows. Anything that gets in the way is not really worth the time.
Same here, so i prefer one line in the terminal over opening a window, navigating with the mouse, searching in lists, clicking all these buttons, navigsting through a file picker… not worth my time (see, it is about speed!)
all working without cli. So maybe Microsoft is the problem here?
Are any of those attempting wireless connections via a 2.4 GHz dongle? Really that’s the only reason you need a driver in the first place. All controllers are otherwise compatible with xinput.
Windows will tell you? If you have a dedicated gpu and want to actually use it you have to go to the website of the chipset vendor
Nah, mate, you don’t got to do anything but hit the windows update button. Proprietary versions ship with Windows which will automatically update with Windows. Windows will also tell you directly in device manager, as I’ve said.
That is just objectively wrong. Simple drivers for simple devices can be implemented perfectly and so can more complicated ones, which they sometimes even are. Tell me which driver you had to “revert”. Was it for a NVIDIA GPU?
Okay, now I am talking to a wall. Like seriously, you’ve never had a driver you needed to specifically update? I am surprised. I’ve had to revert AMD and Nvidia drivers. I also just recently had to uninstall xow and install xone.
Same here, so i prefer one line in the terminal over opening a window, navigating with the mouse, searching in lists, clicking all these buttons, navigsting through a file picker… not worth my time (see, it is about speed!)
I don’t care, my opinion differs. Linux is supposed to be the OS of choice and customization.
Many noname controller disguise themselves as x360 and the main way to get any controller working when a x360 is required is x360ce which disguises any controller as x360. You can even use your keyboard as x360. Plus this is 5 years old plus this is steam only.
Are any of those attempting wireless connections via a 2.4 GHz dongle? Really that’s the only reason you need a driver in the first place. All controllers are otherwise compatible with xinput.
The steam controller has it’s own dongle, with a driver in the kernel, which modern xbox controller could have.
Nah, mate, you don’t got to do anything but hit the windows update button. Proprietary versions ship with Windows which will automatically update with Windows. Windows will also tell you directly in device manager, as I’ve said.
Haven’t used windows 11 yet but in 10 i had to manually install gfx drivers
Okay, now I am talking to a wall. Like seriously, you’ve never had a driver you needed to specifically update? I am surprised. I’ve had to revert AMD and Nvidia drivers. I also just recently had to uninstall xow and install xone.
As I repeatedly said, most drivers are already in the kernel. I have a non-class compliant, 15 yo usb audio interface which is EOL according to the manufacturer and for which the latest 64-bit driver vor windows is for windows 7. It has a driver in the linux kernel and it works. Mainboard soundchip? Driver in the kernel! Network adapter? Driver in the kernel! Firewire pci card? Driver in the kernel! Good wifi/bt chipset? Driver in the kernel! 99% of your hardware require no install of a driver. NVIDIAs driver used to be spotty, but I heard it is better now. With AMD i personally never had any problem. Only drivers I had to manually install in like ever have been for shitty realtek wifi chips and a ffb-wheel (which would have worked but without ffb).
I don’t care, my opinion differs. Linux is supposed to be the OS of choice and customization.
And you’re free to go the slow and time consuming way with gui. Just accept that because of choice and customisation not every fringe detail about your pc will be avaible in a gui unless you choose your custom solution for displaying them.
Many noname controller disguise themselves as x360 and the main way to get any controller working when a x360 is required is x360ce which disguises any controller as x360. You can even use your keyboard as x360. Plus this is 5 years old plus this is steam only.
It doesn’t really matter if they disguise themselves as x360 or not, they are using the same tech 99% of the time.
The steam controller has it’s own dongle, with a driver in the kernel, which modern xbox controller could have.
Steam also has large incentive to put their own driver in the kernel. Why would xbox do such things? Most people use Windows.
Driver in the kernel! 99% of your hardware require no install of a driver.
Sure, yet there are plenty of devices that still require updated drivers. You still need to keep drivers updated for a lot of devices. Some devices are simple and do not need updates. That doesn’t mean an interface to manage them is unneeded because the bulk of drivers don’t need it. There are still plenty that do.
Just accept that because of choice and customisation not every fringe detail about your pc will be avaible in a gui unless you choose your custom solution for displaying them.
“fringe” like game controllers or video cards. Which each competing OS has in a GUI… K. Fringe I guess.
I mean I will give you that it’s a difficult position for Linux but as I am just trying to get things done with my computer, I do not see it as a valid excuse. Especially when PlayStation controllers work just fine on Windows. https://ds4-windows.com/ All done via a GUI. Xbox controllers are the most common controller used. It uses the most common interface to use them, it’s hard to justify them not working out of the box, and on a lot of distros they do work out of the box.
Yes, it can be. But tell me, how do you know what driver is currently being used? (or even what one to install, which Windows will tell you, some distros will tell you what graphics card drivers to install but nothing else.)
Clearly, drivers need to be updated or even rolled back. There have been updates to the open-source drivers. No driver is perfect so they do break things and need to get reverted. I don’t understand your point here because now Nvidia and AMD both use open-source kernel modules. https://github.com/NVIDIA/open-gpu-kernel-modules as well as the AMD ones https://github.com/radeonopencompute/rock-kernel-driver/ these drivers are constantly getting updates.
I don’t care, my opinion differs. Linux is supposed to be the OS of choice and customization. I’d rather not drop down to the terminal. I feel like I can understand a GUI better. It’s not about speed here, it’s about accuracy and ease of use. I want to do the thing so I can move on to doing other things. Maintaining a computer is not a hobby for me, it’s a means to an end. I just want to have my computer work so I can get back to writing code, playing games, and watching shows. Anything that gets in the way is not really worth the time.
Don’t get me wrong, the Linux command line is nice, I’ve written in bash for the last 10 years, it’s far better than Batch or PowerShell and it’s why I use WSL for scripting things on Windows. I write automation for things like build scripts and uploaders and things to make my life easier but I am not about to do this for my computer which should be able to maintain itself for the most part. This is what Windows does and I do not expect less from Linux just because it’s open source.
I complain about the tasks that ideally with a good OS, I should only do once and literally never again until I reinstall my OS for some reason. On Linux a kernel will be updated and my graphics kernel module won’t have a new package for the new kernel and I’ll get bricked.
Ps-controllers also work great on Linux! Have to running in Batocera, absolutely no problem plug&play (well, connect and play).
Are they? I doubt that. I don’t know how good or bad they work on Linux, but PS, Steam-Controller, noname-Controllers from AliExpress, Logitech… all working without cli. So maybe Microsoft is the problem here?
Windows will tell you? If you have a dedicated gpu and want to actually use it you have to go to the website of the chipset vendor, search for the driver, look for the doenload, download it, open the downloaded file, allow changes to the system, click next an obscene amount of times while unchecking all the bloat that is bundled with the driver, wait, click again, and then you’re good to go. Maybe you are asked to log into your geforce experience account, and then you’re good to go. Having some program always running in the background, collecting data, hugging ressources. On Linux you have the choice to install the proprietary or the open source driver. And it just works (at least for AMD since 2019 for me)
In Linux most drivers are kernel modules and you generally don’t interact with them at all. Everything just works. Exceptions are gfx cards and shitty wireless chipsets. Maybe FFB driving wheels. Besides that, every driver update is tested and happens automatically when your package manager installs updates (which can be done via GUI).
That is just objectively wrong. Simple drivers for simple devices can be implemented perfectly and so can more complicated ones, which they sometimes even are. Tell me which driver you had to “revert”. Was it for a NVIDIA GPU?
Same here, so i prefer one line in the terminal over opening a window, navigating with the mouse, searching in lists, clicking all these buttons, navigsting through a file picker… not worth my time (see, it is about speed!)
Instead of doubting, just look it up: https://www.tomshardware.com/news/valve-pc-controller-usage-statistics,37853.html
Are any of those attempting wireless connections via a 2.4 GHz dongle? Really that’s the only reason you need a driver in the first place. All controllers are otherwise compatible with xinput.
Nah, mate, you don’t got to do anything but hit the windows update button. Proprietary versions ship with Windows which will automatically update with Windows. Windows will also tell you directly in device manager, as I’ve said.
Okay, now I am talking to a wall. Like seriously, you’ve never had a driver you needed to specifically update? I am surprised. I’ve had to revert AMD and Nvidia drivers. I also just recently had to uninstall xow and install xone.
I don’t care, my opinion differs. Linux is supposed to be the OS of choice and customization.
Many noname controller disguise themselves as x360 and the main way to get any controller working when a x360 is required is x360ce which disguises any controller as x360. You can even use your keyboard as x360. Plus this is 5 years old plus this is steam only.
The steam controller has it’s own dongle, with a driver in the kernel, which modern xbox controller could have.
Haven’t used windows 11 yet but in 10 i had to manually install gfx drivers
As I repeatedly said, most drivers are already in the kernel. I have a non-class compliant, 15 yo usb audio interface which is EOL according to the manufacturer and for which the latest 64-bit driver vor windows is for windows 7. It has a driver in the linux kernel and it works. Mainboard soundchip? Driver in the kernel! Network adapter? Driver in the kernel! Firewire pci card? Driver in the kernel! Good wifi/bt chipset? Driver in the kernel! 99% of your hardware require no install of a driver. NVIDIAs driver used to be spotty, but I heard it is better now. With AMD i personally never had any problem. Only drivers I had to manually install in like ever have been for shitty realtek wifi chips and a ffb-wheel (which would have worked but without ffb).
And you’re free to go the slow and time consuming way with gui. Just accept that because of choice and customisation not every fringe detail about your pc will be avaible in a gui unless you choose your custom solution for displaying them.
It doesn’t really matter if they disguise themselves as x360 or not, they are using the same tech 99% of the time.
Steam also has large incentive to put their own driver in the kernel. Why would xbox do such things? Most people use Windows.
Sure, yet there are plenty of devices that still require updated drivers. You still need to keep drivers updated for a lot of devices. Some devices are simple and do not need updates. That doesn’t mean an interface to manage them is unneeded because the bulk of drivers don’t need it. There are still plenty that do.
“fringe” like game controllers or video cards. Which each competing OS has in a GUI… K. Fringe I guess.