• 2 Posts
  • 19 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 16th, 2023

help-circle





  • I just finished book 3. Yep. I enjoyed the ride, but the plot seemed a little stretched the more things got expounded on. There was also some unnecessary filler that wore me out to read…

    spoiler

    all the long-form expounding on every crisis, struggling, fighting, chasing puppy etc. scenes.

    spoiler

    The premise of Thurman’s design seemed a little “out there”. Having a competition that each silo was unaware of and only one being allowed to survive seems ridiculous. Humanity is always going to fragment. As populations grow, expand to different territory, local customs and rites will evolve. Limiting things to only one silo is just unnecessary cruelty. The argument of needing the citizens to forget everything about nano tech, and bombs…also ridiculous.

    Nevertheless, I still greatly enjoyed the books.




  • I just finished book two last night. I’m enjoying the ride, but I admit that as the “how we got here” plot has unfolded in book two, I find myself a little perplexed. Maybe I just didn’t understand

    spoiler

    Thurman’s original motive. His line of reasoning is just not connecting for me._

    Nevertheless, the books are riveting and I find myself looking for any spare minutes to pick it back up and continue reading.