Honestly, I’m for it, especially once I read the part about them having been modernized once before. Notre Dame is neither a museum or a ruin (or at least, not a ‘natural’/pre-existing ruin, for lack of a better term); it’s a working church in continuous use and should be treated as such.
Don’t get me wrong, I’m all for them also recreating the 19th century ones (and the 12th century ones too, if they have good references for them), but then displaying them elsewhere as a museum exhibit. (It could be in the context of an exhibit about stained glass art, or one about the history of the cathedral, or even one about the fire and reconstruction specifically.)
Couldn’t they just replicate the original design?
Why? Every single remodelation of any major cathedral included some contemporary elements, why should we stop things as they were in the early 19th century?
