Get the following for $7
- Root
- Sagrada
- Scythe
- Coupon for 50% off Root: The Riverfolk Expansion DLC
Get the following and above for $10
- Wingspan
- Munchkin Digital
- Coupon for 30% off Munchkin Digital: The Unnatural Axe DLC
Get the following and above for $15
- Terraforming Mars
- Terraforming Mars: Prelude DLC
- Terraforming Mars: Hellas & Elysium DLC
- Everdell
Get the following and above for $18
- Dune: Imperium
- Quilts and Cats of Calico
My take:
Bottom line: if you like board games at all, this is well worth the $18 for the whole set.
I’ll give mini-reviews of the ones I know, with a weight rating (complexity, on a scale of 1=“I always bring Apples to Apples to parties” to 5=“I have strong opinions about deckbuilders and area control mechanics”) and an overall rating.
Root: interesting, hugely asymmetrical game where it’s basically like learning to play a new board game for each faction. As such, a bit unwieldy, but interesting at least.
Weight: 4/5
Overall: 3/5
Scythe: complex, deep, and satisfying strategic military industrial war game that can be won without a single battle but may take 2-3 games to really grasp how to succeed. Great steampunk alternate history style, excellent adaptation with asynchronous netplay (play your turn whenever you want and get a notification when it’s your turn again).
Weight: 4.5/5
Overall: 4.5/5
Wingspan: relaxing, fun, and pretty. A great gateway board game if you have a modicum of patience to play until the mechanics “click” for you.
Weight: 3/5
Overall: 4/5
Terraforming Mars: a classic that’s less complicated than it looks and every game is different. Beautiful implementation but the netplay has been buggy forever and I don’t know if they’ve fixed it. You can play asynchronously but back 2020/2021 I had several games go into a broken state that lost our progress.
Weight: 3.5/5
Overall: 4/5 (would be a 5 if the netplay was rock solid)
Everdell: a charming worker placement game that also takes about half a game or so before it clicks. Quite fun once it does, and a great art style.
Weight: 3.5/5
Overall: 4/5
Dune Imperium: brutally complex game that blends deckbuilding and worker placement in an impressively thematic structure with a fantastic digital implementation and async netplay. The game is almost a little TOO intricate though, and it can be easy to lose because you overlooked one of several facets of the strategy. Could be worth playing with a group that are all unfamiliar with it so you can all be terrible together.
Weight: 5/5
Overall: 3.5/5
EDIT: a useful note, I think all of the above games have mobile apps that are cross-compatible, so you can play on the go. Combined with async netplay and a couple friends, this is a great way to get a trickle feed of board gaming in your life.
Thanks for this! Do you know if many of these are viable as single player experiences?
I think most or all of them have AI, so in general, yes, at least a few are. The only ones I can vouch for having played solo are Terraforming Mars (it has a race-the-turn-clock mode I think, along with AI players) and Dune Imperium, if you like getting your ass kicked by robots.
I think the social aspect is one of the best parts of board gaming, so playing solo can feel kind of lonely to me, but it’s definitely a common feature. Async is my favorite though, because you can wrangle a group of friends to play a game over the course of a few days during everyone’s free time. Sometimes everyone ends up online at the same time and you’ll knock out half a dozen turns, other times you’ll do a turn or two in a day.
Thanks! I wasn’t aware of the async option, but it sounds useful. I’m a weirdo who likes playing boardgames against AI, so maybe I’ll read some reviews.
Playing the AI in Dune Imperium was humbling but by the time I got a game going with friends after a few rounds against the computer, I crushed them.