Hi everyone,
I just came across this project called LessPass, which doesn’t require a database as a back-end and can compute passwords on the fly instead of storing them. The idea really intrigued me, and I wanted to know from the community about the experience of using it - did you run into any troubles with it? How does it compare to more traditional password managers (which would need me to think of a back-up strategy)?
Is it possible to back up your passwords from LessPass? Can you use your own passwords when you prefer to? How are the client programs?
Thanks!
It’s a cool concept that quickly falls apart in my opinion:
- It’s not really stateless as soon as a website has certain password requirements. You probably don’t want to remember the configuration of all passwords in your head.
- If the password for a website gets compromised, you have to set the “counter” + 1. Again, not stateless.
- If you have multiple accounts per website, you’ll have to store the site differently (for example including www, not including www) or interlace the counter (odd/even) between the two. This gets more and more messy the more accounts you add, and again, it’s not stateless.
- The master password is the only thing an attacker needs (plus the state mentioned above, but it’s easy to brute force a simple counter). With most other password managers, the attacker needs access to the vault/database and potentially a keyfile, secret and/or some form of second factor.
- Changing your master password because it got compromised or ideally before it gets compromised changes the passwords for all websites.
- You still have to remember your username or login email, so that’s again not stateless if you’re saving it in some sort of LessPass client.
I could probably list a lot of other reasons why it’s not a good idea to use it. There are probably some edge cases where it’s good, for demonstration purposes or training sessions where the participants all need unique (temporary) logins for several services.
You also cannot use it to store secret information like bank account/credit card details, API keys, etc.
Thanks, I’ll keep this in mind.
#3 isn’t true. There’s a username field, so you just put in the username of the alt accounts.
Your point about the master password and two factor is a good one though.
In practice password restrictions are rare (like 1% of sites), but they are problematic when they happen because there’s so many different ways to restrict passwords and trying all combinations is impractical. Needing the counter is exceedingly rare. Remembering the username isn’t a problem, but if you don’t have a consistent policy of always-using-a-username or always-using-the-email (as the lesspass username) it can be difficult to remember that. Similar situation with the URL, if it’s not abbreviated consistently, then it’s a problem.
That said, I still use LessPass for everything and just deal with the edgecase problems.
In my view, both a password file (vault/database) and LessPass are potentially attackable via brute force. I don’t see that one is safer than the other.
Point being that an attacker also needs access to said vault.
The fact that all your passwords change if you change your master password is not great.
They need to use a key to generate the passwords that your master password unlocks or whatever, then you can change the password.
Buuut then you’d have to store the key…
don’t use but sorta concerned about it using the url as those have a tendency to change.
Agreed, if the service changes its name/domain, the password manager basically creates a new password for it whilst the old one becomes irretrievable without some special trickery
The abbreviation method LessPass uses works pretty well. Its usually only a problem with a re-branding, like how wefwef changed to voyager. When that happens it’s not too big of a deal, I just change it to the new thing.
What is a big problem with the URL though is login portals. Like when it’s some conglomerated system that involves a million redirects, and/or a “login with XYZ”. They can get some really weird URLs that have nothing to do with the actual site and those are a real pain.
I won’t use it as there’s always some website with some ridiculous password requirements like “can’t use symbols or numbers, must start with a capital letter, maximum 8 chars”
Cool concept but it doesn’t seem practically viable.
LessPass has the possibility to connect to a database (via its API) to store the configurations made for each site. This API can be used from any of the clients (either the browser extension, the mobile application, etc.).
You set up the DB server wherever you want. If you want something light you can use this implementation. And if you are interested, there is also a command line client.
Great to see you around! Thanks for the comment, I’ll take a look at those!
Despite what others are saying, I’ve been using it for a couple years and it can work great if you’re okay with the trade-offs.
Of the three (Integrity, Confidentiality, Availability) it has better availability than cloud storage which is what I care about. Even when the LessPass site is down, there’s an IPFS version, mirrors, local cache, etc so it’s basically always possible to derive any password.
At a user level, it’s very impractical (and a slight risk) to always retype the master password at every single login screen. However, letting the local autofill save the password doesn’t defeat the point of LessPass. Why? because, if you only use local storage, and you’re traveling and your phone breaks, you’re now locked out of every account. With LessPass, you’re fine as soon as you get an internet connection.
There are a few caveats.
- There’s no global 2factor. Loosing the master password means every site that doesn’t have its own 2factor is instantly fully exposed.
- I do agree there are a few sites where the default options don’t work because of the character restrictions. It’s about 1.2% of websites in my experience, but they are painful exceptions. Basically you have to rely on memory to be able to pick those same settings again. I recently wish there was a unified dataset of which websites had password requirements, and then LessPass would auto check the necessary boxes when the website URL was pasted in. Maybe one day.
- Changing your master password requires changing every single website. If you don’t, then it’s impractical to remember what password was used for what site.
I don’t understand. Why would I save my passwords in the browser of I’m using a password manager?
It avoids the need for cloud storage.
If I’m out somewhere, with no device on me, I can still generate my passwords
New Lemmy Post: Review of LessPass? (https://lemmy.world/post/8715337)
Tagging: #SelfHosted(Replying in this thread will appear as a comment in the lemmy discussion.)
I am a FOSS bot. Check my README: https://github.com/db0/lemmy-tagginator/blob/main/README.md
