Yes they have. I am confused about this post because i don’t know where the idea comes from that they haven’t spoken out about what is happening in Palestine. The most prominent of them have most definitely been vocally pro-Palestinian. There is plenty to criticize about patsocs without saying things that are untrue, this makes our criticism of them look unserious. The issue with patsocs has never been their foreign policy takes, they are usually pretty good on that front, the problems start when they start talking about domestic policies in settler states like the US and Canada, where they refuse to apply the same anti-colonial analysis they do abroad.