Violates the right to your own image. You are not allowed to upload images of a classmate to an AI cloud without asking and neither to reach the generated images around.
It depends on your location, different countries have very different laws.
For example in most countries it’s perfectly acceptable to have someone in a picture that you’re taking in public (for example you’re taking a picture of a building and someone happens to walk by). A notable exception to this is France, where apparently the right to ones own image is quite strong which technically makes most pictures of the Eiffel Tower illegal (as long as any one person is identifiable on it).
Taking (and distributing) a picture specifically of a specific person that’s just doing random stuff in public is already less uniform and varies. There’s often some protection to basically say “no, you can’t make fun of some random person for having the wrong tshirt, they have a right to privacy”. A notable exception to that is usually “public figures” (which mostly means people in political, religious or commercial leadership positions): they mostly just have to accept to be pictured wherever.
Protection for pictures taken in a private is usually the strongest (so yes, if you post a picture of your 3 best friends at a small party in your home, you might have to ask them for permission!)
How all of this applies to pictures that “aren’t real” but look disturbingly so is probably going to be fought over in court for a good while.
Jesus Christ that’s not even close to AI they literally stitched together shit like photoshop
By the way, where do you see that clothoff ( the app mentioned in the article) doesn’t use trained AI models? I’m refraining from visiting their site to check myself as I don’t really want to give them that traffic and I figured I’d ask you direct instead as you already went their to verify I assume)
I didn’t say the app doesn’t use trained models. I said the students didn’t themselves train an embedding or LORA against the other students’ faces in order to generate entirely new pics.
Violates the right to your own image. You are not allowed to upload images of a classmate to an AI cloud without asking and neither to reach the generated images around.
Is that an actual legal right? If you’ve described it accurately, then Facebook and Instagram would be completely illegal
It depends on your location, different countries have very different laws.
For example in most countries it’s perfectly acceptable to have someone in a picture that you’re taking in public (for example you’re taking a picture of a building and someone happens to walk by). A notable exception to this is France, where apparently the right to ones own image is quite strong which technically makes most pictures of the Eiffel Tower illegal (as long as any one person is identifiable on it).
Taking (and distributing) a picture specifically of a specific person that’s just doing random stuff in public is already less uniform and varies. There’s often some protection to basically say “no, you can’t make fun of some random person for having the wrong tshirt, they have a right to privacy”. A notable exception to that is usually “public figures” (which mostly means people in political, religious or commercial leadership positions): they mostly just have to accept to be pictured wherever.
Protection for pictures taken in a private is usually the strongest (so yes, if you post a picture of your 3 best friends at a small party in your home, you might have to ask them for permission!)
How all of this applies to pictures that “aren’t real” but look disturbingly so is probably going to be fought over in court for a good while.
No, human right.
AI generates novel images, though. They are merely trained to produce your likeness. None of the pixels are from any source images.In this case, I’m mistaken. They used a clothing remover app on normal photos and did not train an AI.
Jesus Christ that’s not even close to AI they literally stitched together shit like photoshop
By the way, where do you see that clothoff ( the app mentioned in the article) doesn’t use trained AI models? I’m refraining from visiting their site to check myself as I don’t really want to give them that traffic and I figured I’d ask you direct instead as you already went their to verify I assume)
I didn’t say the app doesn’t use trained models. I said the students didn’t themselves train an embedding or LORA against the other students’ faces in order to generate entirely new pics.
deleted by creator
https://www.echr.coe.int/documents/d/echr/FS_Own_image_ENG
deleted by creator
What worldwide, it’s Spain.
deleted by creator
Dude, dial back the snarkiness.